The Monsters of Templeton by Lauren Groff

A book review

Mostly set in the present day, The Monsters of Templeton includes enough chapters set in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries to count as a historical novel. It's funny and heartbreaking, strange in a way that real life often is.

In the wake of a disastrous love affair, Wilhelmina "Willie" Sunshine Upton has returned to her childhood home in Templeton, a small town in upstate New York—a fictional version of the hometown of nineteenth-century novelist James Fenimore Cooper. In an introductory note, Groff tells readers that when Cooper himself wrote a novel about his hometown, "his facts also went a little awry, so he decided to rechristen his town Templeton, New York." Groff "relaxed and followed his lead."

As Willie arrives home, "the fifty-foot corpse of a monster" emerges from the local lake, looking "like a carp grown enormous, with a carp's fat belly and round eye, but with a long, articulated neck like a ballet dancer's, and four finned legs, plump as a frog's. The ropes of the motorboat had cut into its skin, and the wounds were open to the day, still oozing dark, thick blood.... And, though I had expected the early sun to have warmed it, the monster burned cold, as if its very core was made of the ice some said still existed at the bottom of our glacial lake."

Soon Willie, a descendant of the famous Templeton author Jacob Franklin Temple, has a compelling reason to research her family history. As she starts uncovering monstrous qualities in some of her ancestors, she nevertheless feels driven to keep researching, hoping to satisfy that craving for "a mass of ancestors at our backs as ballast." Because this is fiction, the ancestors, too, can speak. Readers who feel a craving like Willie's and have asked themselves why they want to feel connected even to ancestors who did awful things will find The Monsters of Templeton a compelling story. (2008; 361 pages)